SEC hits Advanced Equities on Bloom deals

Dan Primack

FORTUNE &#8212; For several years, readers have sent sporadic emails about what they considered to be questionable dealings by Advanced Equities – a Chicago-based group best known for marketing large, later-stage venture capital rounds. Now the Securities &#38; Exchange Commission is getting in on the act.<div class="paywall-selector"></div><div class="paywall">
Last week the SEC <a href="http://sec.gov/news/press/2012/2012-191.htm">charged</a> Advanced Equities and its co-founders Dwight Badger and Keith Daubenspeck with misleading investors on a pair of private placement offerings in 2009 and 2010. Or, put more bluntly, of lying.
The issuer – unidentified in SEC docs – was fuel cell company Bloom Energy, which in 2009 hired AE to lead a $150 million Series F offering at a $1.45 billion pre-money valuation ($18.52 per share). Only investors contributing more than $2 million would be able to communicate directly with Bloom, while those under that threshold would be reliant on AE for information.
According to the SEC, Badger told AE brokers in 2009 that “the energy company had more than $2 billion of order backlogs when the backlog never exceeded $42 million.” He also allegedly told them that Bloom “had a $1 billion order from a national grocery store chain even though the store only had placed a $2 million order and signed a non-binding letter of intent for future purchases,” and that it had been granted a $250 million DoE loan when it only had applied for a $96.8 million loan.
Daubenspeck allegedly did not correct Badger during the call, following which AE brokers disseminated the false data to prospective investors. Badger also gave the faulty info directly to investors in AE-sponsored pooled investment vehicles focused on the cleantech space.
The SEC says that Badger also led a deception effort the following year, when AE raised another $47 million for Bloom at the $1.45 billion valuation (including the inflated DoE loan information). Bloom, however, declined to accept the money and AE investors were made whole.
To be sure, this is pretty nasty stuff. And the SEC has gotten a settlement but, from my perspective, one that falls a bit short of the appropriate mark.
Under terms of the cease and desist agreement, AE will: (1) Pay a $1 million penalty, (2) Agree to be censured and (3) Hire an independent consultant to review its sales policies and procedures. Badger – who resigned from AE last month – will pay a $100,000 penalty and be barred for one year from associating with any securities firm. Daubenspeck agreed to pay a $50,000 penalty and a one-year supervisory suspension. None of the three were required to admitting or denying the SEC’s charges.
So where is the settlement insufficient? This one final requirement: AE must “Use its best efforts to locate purchasers for any of its customers who purchased the securities… in 2009 and who wish to sell their securities at a price equivalent to their original purchase price.”
My problem here is that AE is highly unlikely to find buyers for Bloom stock at $18.52 per share. According to SharesPost, the most recent contract came in at just $18.25 per share. Moreover, I’ve heard from multiple sources that Bloom was utterly unable to raise a $150 million funding round that it was seeking <a href="http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2012/06/08/bloom-raising-150-million/">over the summer</a> at $25.76 per share (via AE, of course).
If AE investors want out, shouldn’t AE be required to make up the difference? I have no idea how many investors this would apply to, but it seems odd that AE would pay a $1 million penalty to the SEC but nothing to the actual investors they arguably defrauded. And doesn’t Bloom have some responsibility in all of this, since it outsourced its fundraising to AE? And how about the VCs on Bloom’s board of directors, many of whom have used AE for other portfolio companies?
No response to requests for comment from either AE or Bloom, while the SEC declined to discuss the case beyond what was in the legal filings and press release. Worth noting, however, that Bloom’s voicemail system has an &#8220;investor relations&#8221; option (#3) for those who want “the opportunity to invest in Bloom Energy.”
Sign up for Dan&#8217;s daily email newsletter on deals and deal-makers: <a href="http://gettermsheet.com/" rel="external nofollow" target="new">GetTermSheet.com</a></div>

<a href="http://content.fortune.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/brand.gif"><img class="alignright size-full wp-image-41111" title="brand" src="http://content.fortune.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/brand.gif" alt="" width="198" height="105" /></a>What did Bloom Energy investors know, and from whom did they learn it?

legacy

Finance

What did Bloom Energy investors know, and from whom did they learn it?

SEC hits Advanced Equities on Bloom deals | Fortune

Irina Ivanova

Study looking at AI chatbots in 7,000 workplaces finds ‘no significant impact on earnings or recorded hours in any occupation’

/2025/05/18/ai-chatbots-study-impact-earnings-hours-worked-any-occupation/

Preston Fore

Gen Zers are missing out on hundreds of thousands in free money by ignoring this company policy

/2025/05/18/gen-z-missing-out-free-money-401k-match-company-policy-retirement-savings/

Lila MacLellan

Jewel in a hat on stage at the a wellness festival hosted by Kroger

Here’s how the singer Jewel and the Kroger supermarket giant got entangled in a legal battle over a wellness festival gone wrong

/article/jewel-kroger-lawsuit-rodney-mcmullen-wellness/

Ani Freedman

How much mercury is too much? Here’s what experts want you to know

/well/2025/05/18/mercury-foods-fish/

Emma Burleigh

Woman with Same Ole Line Dudes in Diddy trial line.

This Gen Xer charges $38 an hour to wait in line—including for the Diddy trial and sample sales. Now he’s made a business empire out of standing around all day

/2025/05/18/gen-x-entrepreneur-line-sitting-business-nyc-diddy-trial-sample-sale/

Steven T. Dennis

Bloomberg

New York Republican floats higher tax rate to pay for SALT

/2025/05/17/republican-higher-tax-rate-salt-deduction-trump-big-beautiful-bill/

Beatrice Nolan

Northeastern college student demanded her tuition fees back after catching her professor using OpenAI's ChatGPT 

https://fortune.com/2025/05/15/chatgpt-openai-northeastern-college-student-tuition-fees-back-catching-professor/?itm_source=parsely-api

Sydney Lake

Delta CEO says air traffic control systems are so outdated that some commercial flight routes were faster in the 1950s than they are today

https://fortune.com/2025/05/16/delta-ceo-air-traffic-control-1950s/?itm_source=parsely-api

DOGE said 40% of the Social Security Agency’s calls were 'fraudulent.' Data suggests it was actually less than 1%

https://fortune.com/2025/05/16/doge-social-security-fraud/?itm_source=parsely-api

Stuart Dyos

'Doubt and hesitation' are ripping through the housing market: 'People are starting their home search, then backing out'

https://fortune.com/article/housing-market-buyers-backing-out-mortgage-prices/?itm_source=parsely-api

The Associated Press

A DoorDash driver says he helped steal more than $2.5 million by getting the company to pay for fake deliveries

https://fortune.com/2025/05/14/doordash-driver-wire-fraud-fake-deliveries-sayee-chaitanya-reddy-devagiri/?itm_source=parsely-api

Christiaan Hetzner

Warren Buffett shifts from finance to fun as he dumps Citigroup stake and buys up more shares in alcohol-maker Constellation

https://fortune.com/2025/05/16/warren-buffett-berkshire-hathaway-shifts-finance-to-fun-citigroup-constellation/?itm_source=parsely-api